Dear Miss Emily:

Hi.  I have been in a relationship for a year and half now.  I have known my boyfriend for two years.  We live together and have a close, loving, great relationship.  Only problem is his ex.  He was with her for 3 years and were broken up a year before we met.  She really did a number on him and put him through the ringer.  When we met, he avoided getting too involved until he realized he'd lose me.  His ex recently had a baby and contacted him.  They've been emailing thru facebook since.  Not everyday -- maybe once a month.  Now she's calling him  claiming she's lonely, wants me to be her friend too.  I don't think she's manipulative...not smart enough, and just out there.  She comments on our pics.  She is just always in our business.  When I bring it up he says "I can't control her" or "she doesn't mean any harm".  He left his fb page up one night and I snooped.  (I know I shouldn't but I'm human).  She had emailed him she was sorry for "being a dick" in their past and was glad he was happy.  She blamed it on alcohol and then sent lyrics to their song.  (She is in a committed relationship btw).  He thanked her for the apology...said that would always be "their song...don't tell my girlfriend. Ha ha."  Then he said "I will ALWAYS love you, and miss you tons. Would like to all be friends."  Does that mean he still loves her?  Should I be worried?  It has made me paranoid and obsessed.  We share same phone plan.  He hasn't called or texted her.  He doesn't know I read their messages but, now, I'm always worried he's thinking of her or he's just with me because he can't have her.  A little bit about my past . . .my ex left me for his ex who claimed they were just friends until he got her pregnant.  Anyway, I am not going thru that again.  We've had fights about her before.  When I found a pic of her in his wallet he barely uses.  Or when she calls (he doesn't pick up).  He has deleted her off fb for my sake, but she comes back and makes him feel bad.  It's getting old!  Should I move on?  Appreciate an unbiased opinion.  Maybe he needed to say those things for closure or do I need a reality check?

----------------------Miss Emily's advice-----------------

If you're in a loving relationship with this man, he should have no problem cutting his ex out of his life. What he said in that e-mail to her was completely out of line, and he would turn beet red if he thought you had seen it. And yes he can control his correspondence with her. He can stop it completely. Whether he does it by not responding to her missives, or to tell her outright, "I'm in a relationship with a woman I love. I wish you all the best, but it's time to end our relationship." If he can't do that, I don't know whether he still has strong feelings for her, or he's a wimp who has a thing for nostalgia. Either way, that doesn't help your situation. If the tables were reversed, I think he would take umbrage with it. You're under no obligation to be this woman's friend, nor is he. If she's lonely, she should seek out new friends without having to dip back into a past love relationship. And screw any wanting of closure. All he had to say was "I forgive you," period! You are kind to think she's not smart enough to be manipulative, but the criterion for wanting control over a situation does not require a high I.Q., and you'd be naive to think otherwise. I would get this settled to your satisfaction, or come to terms with the fact that, no matter how little correspondence he has with her, he said he will always love her and misses her tons. It's insulting to you, and duplicitous to my way of thinking.